Good evening, 919 Gang. An early deadline tonight because I
need a very early start tomorrow.
--------------------------------------------------
REBER: The San Diego Press Club awards
have been announced, and the 919 Gang is well-represented.
-----------------------------------------------
CRAIG ROSE
writes:
To Jack: I always found you to be good-natured
colleague and I'm certainly grateful for your work on this blog. But perhaps
your house fire caused trauma because your comments regarding Robert E. Lee are
reprehensible, insensitive and wrong.
I have no idea what has caused you to forget that
Lee and others led an insurrection against this country for the prime purpose
of maintaining slavery. And that wasn't slavery in ancient Rome, it was slavery
at a time when most of humankind recognized slavery for the barbarous and
horrific institution that it was.
In my book, there's no honor in fighting for injustice. An individual might be misguided, sure, but that
shouldn't be construed as anything but sad for the fact they've been blinded to
injustice. And we are all still accountable for our actions.
Advocates for confederacy and its leadership, however, with
Lee, of course included, knew full well what they were doing and deserve
nothing but ignominy.
For the moment, I'm trying to assume you've taken a
desire to be evenhanded way too far, to a fault that has blinded you to
historical realities.
No matter what, I sincerely hope you reconsider your
comments.
BRIAN CLARK writes:
I, too, have relatives who fought on both sides of the
Civil War. And I’m related to Stonewall Jackson’s first wife, who died in
childbirth.
But I’m puzzled by why you consider Robert E. Lee a “true
American hero.” Please explain. An excellent general against incompetent Union
foes, but a hero? For the whole country?
REBER: I’m betting there
are lot of people in this group interested in the Civil War. I recommend a book
called “1858” by Bruce Chadwick. He has interesting profiles on Abraham
Lincoln, Jefferson Davis, Robert E. Lee, Ulysses S. Grant, Stephen Douglas,
John Brown and others as they moved steadily, if unwittingly, toward war. The
only person who comes off very badly in this book is President James Buchanan.
He didn’t see slavery as a major issue, it was an annoying topic that, in his
mind, would wither and evaporate. At a time when compromise and a peaceful, if
gradual, end to slavery might have been possible and should have been pursued,
the president was busy with his political goals and vendettas against his foes.
It is interesting reading.
------------------------------------------------------
REBER: Last night Walt Baranger asked if anyone could interpret this license
plate:
WELTON
JONES writes:
“NYNYT,” Walt?
Not Your New York Times?
MICHAEL GRANT writes:
My flash reaction to Walt Baranger’s license plate was to
remember a kind of false chortle emitted by the Three Stooges.
-----------------------------------------------------
Wow, Jack. What were you cooking? We had an oven fire once, but nothing as dramatic. Our older daughter, a graduate of culinary school, managed to set a pan of brownies on fire while she was baking them. We watched through the glass window in the oven door. Very entertaining.
REBER: The 5-year-old who
lives down the road suggested that this was the most interesting thing that has
ever happened at our house.
-----------------------------------------------
REBER: I forgot to wind my sun dial,
and I missed wishing a Happy Birthday to Charlie Starr and Kelly Thornton on
Oct. 31.
P.O. Box 2239
Ramona, CA 92065
U.S.A.





